Aspiring to ethical living is becoming less easy and more admin than I would really like. Turns out, everything I want needs looking into.
So, this week, I need a new duvet. I don’t own a winter duvet, and I’m geekily excited about getting one and turning my old, thinning summer one into a quilt. Plus, it’s September. The chill is in the air.
So I checked out Ikea’s website, and there’s one I like, not too pricey. And then, I think about cotton. And the ethics of cotton. And I got into a massive duvet labyrinth, that’s a lot less comfy than it sounds.
Because it turns out (John Lewis’ website brought this to light for me) feathers are an issue too – free range feathers had never occurred to me, let alone the industry evil I’ve learnt about now, that is plucking live poultry for their feathers …shudder. But I have no idea whether that’s where the feathers in my pillows has come from.
Erk. More faff and research at my end. But sure, for the poor ducks and geese, fair cop.
Meanwhile, cotton: major child labour industry, notably highlighted in Uzbekistan, the world’s third largest cotton exporter, according to some people called the Environmental Justice Foundation. Plus, non-organic involves pesticides that (may) damage the surrounding plantlife across the huge swathes of land cotton is farmed, and expensive GM cotton seeds that up production (if they yield a harvest, which like all seeds they sometimes don’t depending on the weather) often trap farmers in debt cycles.
All a bit mind boggling when all I wanted to do was buy a duvet. And organic usually means pricey, and all in all the consumerist bit of me wishes none of this was an issue and I could just buy my damn duvet. But it is an issue, and I’d rather sleep soundly at night.
I trawled Ikea’s substantial self-deprecating ‘our responsibility’ > ’the never ending list’, which I’m finding is exactly what ethical consumer-ing is. But wanting it on paper that their ideals and lovely initiatives make it as far as their actual duvets, I emailed. What puzzled and still puzzles me is, shouldn’t it cost more to have these guarantees? John Lewis costs a lot, and they have these ethical banners everywhere. So I was figuring, there must be a catch. Ikea emailed me back, (This is not an advert for Ikea. I’m just telling a story. God knows the next installment might be an exposé). Should I take their word for it? This was their email:
Dear Ms Cowley,
I am in receipt of your email and I have contacted the relevant departments within IKEA in the UK who can specifically advise me in relation to your questions:
The range you detail adheresto the fair trade initiatives, IKEA globally disassociates itself from Child Labour and works actively against it and the comment in relation to free range and poultry is also correct.
I am hopeful that this will assist you, and that you enjoy the IKEA shopping experience,
Regards
a. n. employee—————-
IKEA UK and IE Customer Services Specialist
Would you trust a response like that? My ‘comment in relation to free range and poultry is also correct’? And, is that because they do or don’t meet your concern for these issues, (i.e. you’ve got some concern), or because they’ve said enough and I’ve gone into this more than enough for how much you’re bothered? Answers on a post (/comment) please…
or a postcard, if you’re that way inclined.
Environmental Justice Foundation on cotton: http://www.ejfoundation.org/page141.html
And GM cotton in India: http://www.pbs.org/wnet/wideangle/episodes/the-dying-fields/global-cotton-industry/bt-cotton-farming/1949/
Better Cotton, interestingly, was set up by GAP, H&M, IKEA and Adidas, along with various others including Oxfam and WWF. Who knew. http://www.bettercotton.org
POSTED 27.09.10 BY: grace |
Comments (1)