Blog

Features of New Monasticism I – Belief as faithful action

Rightly people have started to ask me the question, what is new monasticism in our current UK context? To begin to answer this, I am going to start putting up blog postings coming out of the discussions I am involved with at the national CofE Advisory Council for Religious Communities and Diocesan Bishops that I was co-opted onto last year. We have been working hard on a proposal to assist the Church to discern, recognise and nurture New Monastic Communities as authentic ‘Acknowledged Religious Communities’. In this document, there is a section on features of new monasticism that I will be using in this blog for our reflection, to which people are more than welcome to respond in the comment section.

So we start with the focus on ‘belief as faithful action’, (you may want to listen to the current podcast entitled followers of Jesus ….. as it does relate to this subject to).

For Monks, Nuns and Friars – there has been the commitment to take very seriously, the stories of Jesus Christ in the Gospels. In these texts, Jesus gives a number of directions and commandments about faith in action. For Jesus it seems – faith is very much about doing – not just thinking. What we do says as much about who we really are. So Jesus’ commandment to Love God, love ourselves and love others – is the central teaching for a faith that leads to action. Also there is the calling to love your enemies, love your neighbour, and a strong call to non-violence. These callings then are very important to new monastics. As illustrated by St Pauls writing in Galatians 5:19-24 there is a strong commitment to the fruit of the Spirit around love, patience, humility in the place of anger, fear and pride.  So how we do community, how we live out and treat each other not just in ecclesial communities, but also how we relate to people has a huge focus in this model of church.

So for new monastics, life then is about belief as faithful action or what is called orthopraxis (right acting or doing). This is why New Monastics have a Rhythm of Life – of the balance of activity of worship, mission and community. So the Moot Community for example has aspirations, spiritual practices and postures which are about how we live as much as they are about what we believe. This is because new monastics believe strongly in what St Francis kept talking about – experience that leads to understanding. So why is this so important? Well as the cynical but truthful video below demonstrates (sorry for the expletives) is that the world is sick of people who call themselves Christians but do not act like they are followers of Jesus Christ. Rightly – the world is not happy with forms and expressions of Christianity that are oppressive or violent in orientation. So for New Monastics – it is about getting back to the basics. The calling to live with the God of love as the orientation of your life, and the struggle to live with gentleness, kindness and humility in a world dominated by power and the ego, and our increasingly post-christendom context.

I think the video below demonstrates this. It is uncomfortable to listen to, because something of what is being said is absolutely true. And for non-Americans – lets not be smug. These same issues are alive and well in the UK Church and beyond. My hope is that New Monasticism in all its smallness and fragility, can play its part in contributing to a more loving expression of church that seeks to follow Christ rather than act like it is God. In this way we hope that New Monastic Christians can be whole, balancing head, heart and wellbeing or rather Orthodoxy, Orthopraxis and Orthopathy and follow Christ so that we can grow into our potentials as human becomings, where discipleship then becomes a whole of life pursuit about living and doing that brings life to ourselves, to others and to the ecosphere. In my next blog, I will try to unpack what the three levels of aspirations, spiritual practices and postures represent. See the vid below! Any questions – do use the comments section.

POSTED 23.01.12 BY: ianmobsby | Comments (5)

5 Responses to “Features of New Monasticism I – Belief as faithful action”

  1. On January 24th, 2012 at 3:30 pm Mark Christian said:

    Really? You choose this video of making fun of and disliking Christians to exemplify what you believe in? The video generalizes that the majority of Christians are violent. Where does he get his statistics from? This video is full of illogical statements. So, if you put down other Christians, in order to build yourselves up, this is what you think Christianity is about? “Well as the cynical but truthful video below demonstrates (sorry for the expletives) is that the world is sick of people who call themselves Christians but do not act like they are followers of Jesus Christ. Rightly – the world is not happy with forms and expressions of Christianity that are oppressive or violent in orientation.” I agree that each one of us is held accountable for the degree that we follow the 1st 2 commandments to love, but all Christians including yourselves are sinners saved by grace, the moment that we have 100% accuracy on practicing this love is the moment we enter heaven. So, be careful in pride that thinks we have a better grasp on what love is, outside of supporting each other to do as God commands. So really, you choose this video?

  2. On January 24th, 2012 at 4:45 pm Aaron Kennedy said:

    Hi Mark Christian! Thank you for commenting. i thank you for reinforcing the need for self-critique and non dualistic approach. we must remain true to our prophetic voice, but we must also avoid any “us versus them” and “we’re better than you” mindsets. … we are in fact those hypocrites, we are those learning and failing to follow christ, relying on justification by faith, as gift, not as something earned. please forgive any perceived implication that as fellow christians we better than you. we stand together, united by god’s gratuitous love for us revealed in jesus. thank you for reminding us of this.

    I must say, however, that I think Ian has specifically advised non-American Christians (Mooters) not to be smug, and says “These same issues are alive and well in the UK Church and beyond.” And i believe he is using the video to illustrate an alarming loss of respect for christians in secular society at large – and in this case the judgement is being made on what seems to be a faithful reflection of the church’s own terms of self definition. Does the validity of the hypocrisy not burn you? it makes me yearn for a body of christ more alive to the purposes set out in the ministry of christ.

    And the specific charge being raised in the video (not practicing what we preach) is specifically the topic of Ian’s post, so I think it is an appropriate video to have chosen.

    I am sorry you have read in Ian’s post a lot of haughtiness and judgementalism which i myself don’t read. Ian is encouraging new monastics to become faithful to the lives christ calls us all to live, and it happens to be a value of new monasticism to “get practical”, like the old monastics, and to really concretely live out in practice what it means to be a christian.

    without the ability to self-critique the church cannot remain true to its calling to be christ-like. christ was continually point up the hypocrisy and idolatry of yahweh’s official representatives on earth. and he stood in a very strong Old Testament tradition, that of the prophets. so there’s a very legitimate place for challenging our fellow christians, and being challenged by them.

    thank you for contributing.

  3. On January 25th, 2012 at 12:54 pm ianmobsby said:

    Aaron, you have articulated what I aimed to say far more eloquently than I can. We really need to get you writing more as you have a real gift. I echo everything Aaron has said – particularly the angle that I was writing this reflecting on how much I am a hypocrite. I think the challenge to progressive expressions of Christianity – and I see this in myself – that we talk the talk of justice – ecological, economic and social, and we talk about following the way of Jesus – but I see in me a resistance to live it practically. We are avoid ant or minimalise participation in community and see it as a chaw.

    At a time when our culture is in crisis and I think there is a complete lack of vision and direction in every area of life including the Church (which I want to argue is because of the short term consumptive world view that many of us hold I know I do) that we find it difficult to live it. So watching the video is to me prophetic – God in the Bible particularly the Hebrew Scriptures used outside voices when the Priests and Prophets had been consumed by what ever – and for me – this film is not only some atheist guy having a go – I deeply sense God challenging me through it to face up to the gulf of how I live, and how I say I live. Change starts with me, and through New Monasticism, I hope at 44 I might at last truly be a novice of the calling God has for Christians. I have been a Christian and now an Ordained Priest for 23 years, and at the age of 44 – I am only just getting what I think Jesus wants of me in this life – where I am over half way! So that is what I am feeling.

    I am currently in Bristol – and I sense the pain of a City and culture which does not know how to respond to economic recession – the sense of overwhelmedness is intense. This is entirely the time when we as Christians should be living out a sense of hope that the Christ-life came to restore and challenge, and encourage us to live another way radically focused on the Kingdom of God. So hence I join in with the Jesus prayer that the desert mothers and fathers prayed every day and now so relevant for me right here right now – Jesus Christ Son of God, have mercy on me, have mercy on me a sinner.

  4. On January 25th, 2012 at 2:08 pm Mark Christian said:

    I am not going to watch the video again but one of the statements that stands out in my memory is “Gandhi is so Christian; He is Hindu.” Could you explain from a Christian point of view what this is supposed to mean and how it supports your Christian perspective? I won’t waist my time ripping apart each point of this video and the illogical statements made. I think there are many Christian speakers with videos that could have been chosen that would have stated better for you the need for Christians to act in a way consistent with God’s commandments.

    Addressing your we versus them attitude. You make statements that stand on the premise that other Christians do not do these things and therefore are worthy of noting as unique. With these statements, you also neglect that throughout history and continuing until today, not all the groups, who you have selected to state as having commitment have shown the love as we are commanded by God. Again, we as Christians are given the 2 greatest commandments to love, God says we need to work on to perfect. He also knows that we will only be 100% pure in this love, when we get to heaven, which shows are continued need of Him. I can tell you of another community who has honest desire to live “better than other Christians” and the problems that have occured within this group. And, this statement
    “My hope is that New Monasticism in all its smallness and fragility, can play its part in contributing to a more loving expression of church that seeks to follow Christ rather than act like it is God.” To whom are you comparing yourself when you make the statement “seeks to follow Christ rather than act like it is God”? It appears to everyone that you are making a generalized statement against all other Christian churches, and therefore Christians. Really you think this accusation demonstrates the love that your community is supposed to have?

  5. On January 25th, 2012 at 2:38 pm James_Vincent said:

    As to whether Gandhi was a Christian, I’ll leave that to God. Which, if I think about it, is probably the case for everyone. Some of the aspects in the video are quite difficult to dispute: in particular, the determination of many Christians (American Christians in particular) to go war. As a Brit, I also find the American attitude to guns completely baffling. On the news the other day was a woman in South Carolina who said that Jesus had told her to open a gun store: which seems to contradict a lot of what I understand about Christ.

    But I think it’s a good thing that Christianity in America is still valued. I think Alistair Campbell’s statement that “we don’t do God” is one of the most saddening comments made about British politics and society in a very long time (alongside “there’s no such thing as society”). The contradictions in the Christian Right do need to be highlighted, as they are in this video (a pro-life position seems a bit odd compared to pro-capital punishment and pro-war). But the Christian Left seems to get off lightly quite a lot. Apologising for this, that and the other, and turning welcoming, charity and tolerance into a kind of whatever-you-want-religion. One church I know seriously considered allowing Muslims to serve Communion on the grounds of social cohesion!

    Humility was quite a big thing for Jesus (ironic, as he of all people didn’t need to be). Maybe if we as Christians were more humble individually and as a church we would more acceptance in demonstrating the point of Christ’s teaching.